What is Benchmarking in Construction Industry

In construction benchmarking is the practice of comparing business processes and performance metrics to other construction companies.

It's considered a strategic management tool to identify areas for improvement.

Particularly, in the context of construction, this performance evaluation can lead to better project management, increased productivity, and cost-friendly opportunities. 

In this blog, we’ll review its process, purpose, relevance in the industry, and some tips for nailing benchmarking like a pro.

So let's start understanding the concept and significance of construction benchmarking, including its fundamentals and challenges. 

‍

What is Benchmarking in Construction?

Benchmarking is a process where construction companies measure their business success against competitors to discover ways of improvement.

It helps when your construction projects require careful planning, precise execution, and well-calculated budgeting.

It's the yardstick for success measuring and comparing the performance, and practices against your competitors. 

You can apply benchmarking to different aspects of construction projects such as management, scheduling, cost control, safety, and sustainability.

‍

Purpose and Benefits of Construction Benchmarks

Do you know construction benchmarking is more than just a box to tick? 

Does it serve an important purpose?

Here's how? 

• Improves Performance: It recognizes areas to excel and improve by comparing performance metrics.

• Brings Competitive Advantage: Helps to gain a competitive edge in the construction market by analyzing competitors’ performance and strategies. 

• Enhances Productivity: When you adopt best practices, it can lead you to enhanced efficiency and productivity in construction projects. What's the result? Fast project completion and cost savings.

• Mitigates Risks: Enabling proactive risk management, assists you in recognizing potential risks and pitfalls through studying other companies' experiences.

• More Control: Relying on benchmarking, you can feel more authorized to take control of your projects. Whether you do it as a client, contractor, or insurer. 

‍

Types of Construction Benchmarking 

Have a look at some common techniques in construction: 

Internal Benchmarking

Internal performance evaluation means to compare metrics and practices from different units.

It includes product lines, departments, programs, geographies, etc, within the construction company. 

Providing important information on past projects, an analysis hands you the playbook for creating internal best practices.

Without bias, you can review past projects by simply focusing on: 

• What strategy resulted in success and what has failed? 

• What were the KPIs (key performance indicators)

• Did your team take action on time and hand off them easily?

• Was there any excessive number of changes? How did that change happen? 

• Did the documents of the contract set up project roles, responsibilities, and obligations efficiently? 

• What could be improved and how could you do that? 

• Who is required to implement the improvements?

By reading between the lines at your company’s strengths and weaknesses, internal performance evaluation helps identify steps.

It assists in implementing more productive policies and procedures in the future. 

‍

External Benchmarking

It involves a comparison of metrics or practices of one construction organization to one or many others.

It's all about how your customer measures their performance.

Like it or not, when you step into the market you are thrown into the ring with the competition.

External benchmarking helps your business remain competitive and ensure you meet all the dynamic industry standards for excellence. 

It answers queries like: 

• What is your standing in the construction arena? 

• Where do you fall if you compare your project size and type? 

• What's the duration of multiple projects and does your portfolio meet the requirements? 

• How many change orders are admissible for a defined project profile in a construction region? 

• What's the range of markets for specific impacts like cost and time? 

• What's the average impact? 

• How can you do your comparison with other companies doing similar projects locally?

‍

Strategic Benchmarking

It is all about stacking your business strategy up against the high-performing construction companies.

To identify trends, differences, opportunities, and strategic goals, you can think beyond your organizational standards.

It puts you on the right track to find innovative approaches.

To advance in particular areas, analyze the following: 

• What's the particular solution working for other companies? 

• How did they find such a solution? 

• Will it be suitable for you? 

• What do you have to do to adapt this to your business strategy? 

Reassessment is a natural part of the strategic evaluation process.

By discovering the flaws and strengths of your strategy and the high-achieving companies, you better understand their work.

Create a unique strategy by learning about your company and other companies.

You will gain insights about their marketing, management process, leadership approach, and future vision. 

‍

Competitive Benchmarking

To measure the performance of your company, you need to compare it to your competitor through competitive performance evaluation. 

Since your business wants to win the bid against the competitors, this is a smart move.

For instance, if a company wins a project, you can analyze its process and performance. 

In this way, you can do identification of gaps within your services. 

‍

Functional Benchmarking

The other method of comparative analysis is functioning, one assisting you to look beyond the construction industry.

Comparing implementations of other industries facing challenges alike, you can make informed decisions. 

These challenges are: supply chain management or safety protocols. 

‍

Best-in-Class Benchmarking

In addition to the above, best-in-class benchmarks enable you to set ambitious performance targets. 

How can you do that? 

Just identify and compare industry leaders and organizations who are known for being the best. 

‍

Historical Data Benchmarks

It involves data analysis from past construction projects to establish reference points for estimating costs.

When dealing with projects having compatibility with previous undertakings, this type of benchmark is valuable in particular.

The process includes the following steps typically: 

• Analysis of Past Project Data: Construction estimators collect information from completed projects. They count material costs, subcontractor rates, labor hours, equipment expenses, and overall project durations.

• Adjustment for Inflation and Economic Changes: It helps to adjust the historical data to reflect the present-day cost environment by using appropriate indices or inflation factors. 

This method is used to create reference points for similar efforts in the future. 

‍

Project Benchmarking 

During the project benchmark process, the estimators estimate the performance of the construction project to other similar projects.

This helps to assess the tenders from suppliers and contractors by highlighting those specific areas that do not provide good value for money. 

‍

Construction Benchmarking Process

When it comes to an understanding of what makes other competitors successful, this metric can help.

Determining what factors can be optimized to see the bigger picture. 

So how can you implement a successful quality assessment process? 

Here is a step-by-step process listed below: 

‍

Determining Problematic Areas

First of all, the initial step is to spot key performance indicators (KPIs).

The more you involve KPIs the more you get productivity rates, project completion time, cost predictability, profit margins, etc. 

What is the best way to save all gathered data like KPIs? 

Leverage construction management software. Using this tool helps you input, edit, save, and access information and files within less time.

Being a project leader, you can supervise everything easily. 

‍

Collection of Data

It's considered the most labor-intensive part of the measurement process.

Factors that require assessments and some crunching are tough to pin down.

Case in point are schedule performance and productivity. 

Moreover, leveraging the scoring system is very helpful for those who don't have concrete numbers to study and analyze customer satisfaction.

Analysis and Comparison 

If you want to expose any deficiencies in your company’s performance, analyze the numbers proficiently. 

By doing so, you can determine both weaknesses and strengths of the operations smartly. 

Be alert! 

The right time to ship is once you have nailed down the financial gaps and performance.

Over and above, your project leaders need to prioritize task scheduler software. 

Increasing productivity within the team becomes easier through this advanced tool. 

‍

Implementation and Monitoring 

Furthermore, collaborating with staff is necessary to implement practical solutions.

As an example, if you have selected external productivity analysis, you have to identify the best way to adapt any effective methods. 

When implementing changes, monitor the results cautiously. 

‍

Repetition of Process 

Next is repetition. 

Repeat the whole process while incorporating the lessons you learned from the current and past implementations necessarily. 

Redoing this program is helpful if your company wants to benefit from the benchmarking process and obtain the desired results. 

You are required to consider repetition. The reason is that it highlights mistakes and keeps methods valid over the long haul. 

To illustrate, when it comes to changes in organizational priorities, it should be reflected in the KPIs. 

Today, there is advanced software like Clue to help repeat the process so you get real-time collaboration. 

‍

Management Support 

At all costs, management is important to support all measurement efforts and required changes. Providing feedback, let participants step up their game and maintain the team’s morale. 

Two essential management concerns for a construction company are: 

• Profit margins

• Payroll

It leads towards cross-examining the other involved areas like costs of subcontracting and occupancy. 

‍

What is the Role of Technology in Benchmarking

Construction Estimating Software

Important Features: 

• Quantity Takeoff: It facilitates automated quantity takeoff by pulling precise measurements straight from digital blueprints and models.

• Cost Databases: Providing a vast repository of benchmark data, this tool offers extensive cost databases: material prices, labor rates, and equipment costs. 

• Parametric Estimating: It allows your estimators to create estimates based on predefined cost models and factors. It smooths out the estimation process.

• Cost Tracking: Construction estimation software helps project managers compare actual costs with roughly calculated values through cost tracking at once.

• Scalability: Projects of varying sizes and complexities are handled by estimating software. 

• Reporting: It has robust reporting features allowing clear and organized presentation of estimates. You can communicate your findings to the stakeholders easily.

• Cloud-Based Estimates: There's no limit now you can submit material orders and RFQs anytime, from any place having internet access. 

• Consistency: When you use construction Estimating software, it instills a standardized approach to estimating procedure. Make certain all project estimates follow the same rules and formats.

‍

Integration with Analyzed Data

‍This software helps to: 

• Merge external benchmark databases.

• Incorporating historical and industry-specific information into estimates. 

• Enables estimators to adjust assessment (to fit the unique quirks of each project). It adds locations, materials, and labor conditions.

Additionally, technology has a significant role in validating comparative data.

By cross-referencing multiple sources, estimators can ensure data accuracy and reliability.

‍

Building Information Modeling (BIM)

‍

How to Leverage BIM for Accurate Estimates? 

Here's the scoop: 

• 3D Visualization: BIM modeling offers a 3D digital representation of the construction project. Increasing the level of understanding of project scope and complexity improves the accuracy of estimates. 

• Quantity Takeoff Automation: On top of that, BIM automates quantity takeoff by extracting data directly from the model. It reduces the manual errors and accelerates the estimation process.

• Clash Detection: The clash detection feature is amazing, helping to recognize potential conflicts between building components. It downsizes the costly design changes during construction.

• Change Management: This software supports efficient management of construction design changes. Giving estimators with updated data for accurate cost projections. 

• Standardized Data Inputs: Up-to-date data is important so the BIM software helps establish and maintain data standards within the model. Ensuring all teams have access to consistent and reliable information.

‍

Helping to Extract Data for Comparative Analysis

BIM can be linked to historical project data, so you can get an abundance of benchmark information for estimating future projects. 

In addition to this, estimators can compare past projects with the current BIM model.

By doing so, they identify similarities and differences, filling you in more precise cost estimations.

Finally, this latest software generates performance metrics, such as labor productivity and material usage.

It can be leveraged as a benchmark for future projects.

In the construction sector, the integration of technology significantly enhances the validity and efficiency of benchmarking. 

Resulting in improved cost management and successful project outcomes. 

‍

What are Common Challenges?

For over a century, it has been an important part of business activities, especially in the construction sector. 

Common challenges are: 

• Different levels of construction crew skill and competency

• Setting on the key performance indicators (KPIs) 

• Lack of information about project specifications and design

• Scope changes during the planning or construction phase

• Complex projects with unique designs or innovative technologies lacking historical data

• Varying nature of the construction market including material and labor cost fluctuations

• Inadequate data or limited access to relevant and reliable historical information 

• Utopian estimates 

• Outdated estimation tools or software 

• Tight project schedules

• Seasonal variations influence production planning by dictating demand patterns.

‍

Tips for Successful Construction Benchmarking 

Learn some practicable tips to make sure the time and effort needed to establish benchmarks add value to future projects.

Gather Proper Information

Keep in mind that you have to get enough data if you want meaningful analysis while doing benchmarking.

It's especially vital for the construction sector. A place where a wide range of projects, tasks, and requirements can result in outliers and bias.

Doing large sampling of data makes it easier to separate meaningful results and trends from metrics only about a specific project type.

‍

Identify Authentic Data Sources

Trustworthiness is the ultimate goal of any business. Therefore the quality of collected data counts.

Using the same tools and processes for every project, you should  

complete and collect data in a repeatable way. 

‍

Normalize the Gathered Data 

The other chief element of this procedure is data normalization.

Without skewing the findings, it allows information from different types of construction projects, tasks, or locations.

This process leans on statistical methods.  Accounting for differences by adapting or “normalizing” the raw data.

‍

Focus on Implementation

You must prioritize the implantation process in benchmarking.

Through a phased approach, contractors learn how benchmarks are used in construction targeting the most important areas first.

Before moving to another benchmark, the collection of data from a single metric (such as framing time per square foot of floor space) authorizing contractors to: 

• Streamline the data collection process.

• Identify roadblocks.

• Check software tools. 

‍

Collaborate with Stakeholders

Cooperating with owners and contractors to get them aligned on data collection practices.

It helps them to understand the purpose of benchmarking.

You can nip errors or misunderstandings in the bud before they corrupt the data set. 

Everyone has a say in choosing useful metrics to benchmark through this commitment. 

‍

Keep up with Construction Industry Trends

Remaining consistent with industry norms and standards is important while developing your strategy.

You can stack up the results or pool data between multiple organizations and contractors when different companies are on the same page. 

According to Spendolini, benchmarking provides new ideas to the organization. 

‍

Prioritize Data Accuracy and Reliability

You can ensure data accuracy by: 

• Establishing a network of reliable industry contacts.

• Utilizing reputable construction data providers.

• Collaborating with experienced.

Cross-reference this data from various sources and validate historical data against completed projects.

In this way, you can rectify discrepancies.Have to deal with incomplete data? To maintain relevance, update benchmark databases regularly.

When dealing with incomplete data, estimators can make educated assumptions.

They consider similar projects' data to fill the gaps, ensuring a more comprehensive analysis.

‍

Address Project Uniqueness

• Project Segmentation: Create distinct segments or work packages of projects. Then choose a benchmark by reviewing the unique characteristics of each segment.

• Parametric Models: Use parametric estimation models. These models are designed to speculate project-specific features. 

• Key Milestones: Adjust the benchmark at significant project milestones after reviewing it. It helps to account for scope changes and fresh data.

• Learning from Experience: Make overall scanning of your completed projects to understand benchmarks. Analyze where the criterion is successful and where you need adjustments. 

‍

Conclusion 

Wrapping up, benchmarking in the construction industry is a powerful tool.

Managing performance improvement, enhancing efficiency, and getting a competitive advantage.

It can be made more easy with construction management software such as Clue. 

By measuring up to industry best practices, construction companies can find weak spots and adopt sustainable strategies.

As data is the key to predictability, and predictability leads to better quality for clients. 

‍

FAQs

What are the Basics of Construction Estimates?

The basics of construction estimates involve the analysis of various elements. It incorporates labor, materials, equipment, subcontractor costs, overheads, and contingencies. Construction estimation is the assessment and calculation of projects. 

What are Those Factors that Influence Construction Costs? 

There is a wide range of factors: 

• Project scope
• Location
• Labor cost
• Material cost
• Equipment expenses
• Project schedule
• Site conditions
• Regulatory compliance
• Economic factors
• Contingencies