What is an Experience Modification Rating (EMR Rating)?
Oded Ran, CEO and Co-Founder of Clue since 2019, expertly integrates AI and data tools to revolutionize construction equipment management and maintenance, positioning Clue as a premier software choice in the construction industry.
An Experience Modification Rating (EMR) adjusts workers' comp premiums based on a company's claims history, impacting insurance costs by reflecting safety performance
Since the 1980’s it has been a wide and common practice to utilize a company’s safety records to gauge its general competence when it comes to employee safety.
As safety requirements have become more stringent, businesses today are increasingly dedicated to workplace compliance.
To gauge this compliance, a trend has emerged in using an indicator initially developed in the insurance sector to determine policy rates.
This indicator, now widely adopted to assess a company's commitment to safety and overall management effectiveness, is known as the experience modification rate (EMR), modification rate, or simply MOD.
Essentially, the EMR rating has become the industry's equivalent of a credit rating.
What is EMR Experience Rating?
The cost of workers' compensation insurance premiums is determined by an experience modification rating or EMR—also known as an XMOD rating or factor.
Similar to a credit score or driving record, the EMR is viewed by third parties as a predictor of future risk.
In the construction industry, insurance firms assess future risk and historical injury costs by analyzing an organization's EMR.
Although only claims data from the past three years are used, your EMR is based on actual insurance and workers' compensation claims recorded with the National Council on Compensation Insurance (NCCI) over the last five years.
An EMR is a method used by insurance carriers to adjust workers' compensation insurance premiums based on the expected losses from claims within each insured company.
Similar to how lenders determine loans and interest rates based on a client's credit rating, an Experience Modification Rating measures a company's risk level, just as a credit score assesses financial risk.
Employers with strong safety performance indicators will reflect this in their EMR, resulting in lower premiums for their workers' compensation insurance.
Calculation of EMR Rating
EMRs are probably not a concern for many small business owners because they only apply to workers' compensation premiums that total at least $5,000 annually.
Because each state has its own set of rules and criteria, calculating an EMR can be challenging. To crunch these figures for their brokers, insurance companies employ professionals who examine workers' compensation claims, actual losses, and loss rates.
Although many states have their own classification techniques and class codes, the calculation may include your payroll data, claims history, and an industry risk factor, such as the National Council on Compensation Insurance (NCCI) classification codes.
The EMR rate is determined using a methodology that compares the actual losses incurred by your company to the expected losses within your industry.
The formula is:
EMR = (Actual Losses / Expected Losses)
A business with an EMR of 1.00 has a claims history that aligns with industry expectations.
An EMR exceeding 1.00 indicates increased risk and potential cost increases, while a lower EMR signifies a superior safety record and results in lower insurance rates.
Your actual losses are the total claim costs that your insurance company has paid on your behalf over a certain period.
In contrast, expected losses are calculated based on the size and classification of your industry. The average EMR is always set at 1.00, regardless of the industry.
Factors that Influence the EMR Rating Calculation
Claims Frequency
These include the number of claims filed by a company.
Small claim frequencies can also be a problem because they signal increased risk and thus can harm the EMR.
Claims Severity
The nature of a claim is also essential; the level of the claim’s severity or its cost contributes greatly.
Once in a while claims often cost high and this will lead to a high EMR because they will indicate high future expected losses.
Payroll Size
The size of the payroll of the company can be referred to to judge the scale of business.
It is evident that companies having a large employee base, pay higher premiums due to increased expectations for large losses hence affecting the EMR.
Industry Classification
All the companies are then grouped depending on the kind of job they undertake.
Various industries have different levels of risks which are taken into consideration.
For instance, anticipated losses are usually higher among construction companies as compared to desk jobs.
Primary and Excess Losses
The EMR calculation divides the losses into primary and excess levels.
The first part of a claim is more heavily weighted in the EMR calculation because it is believed to be more indicative of future risk.
The remaining part of more significant claims, which is known as the excess losses, has a minimal impact on the EMR.
Time of Data
The EMR calculation typically uses data from the preceding three complete policy years, excluding the current year.
This period is intended to provide the company with a clearer picture of its recent safety performance.
Expected Losses
Expected losses are the predicted losses estimated based on standard industry costs and the classification of the company.
This figure represents what an average company in the same industry with a similar payroll budget would be expected to incur in terms of losses.
Interpreting EMR Rating Scores - A Breakdown
What is a High EMR?
A high EMR typically indicates that a company has experienced more frequent or severe workers' compensation claims compared to the industry average.
When a company’s EMR exceeds 1.0, it signifies that the company’s safety performance is below the industry standard, suggesting higher risk levels.
This can lead to increased scrutiny from insurance providers and a rise in insurance costs.
What is a Low EMR?
The EMR scale typically ranges from 0.0 to 5.0.
The lowest possible EMR is 0.0, although achieving this is extremely rare due to the likelihood of some claims occurring over time.
More commonly, a low EMR is around 0.7 to 0.8, which indicates excellent safety performance and fewer claims than the industry average.
Having a low EMR offers numerous benefits:
- It leads to lower insurance costs, particularly for workers' compensation, thereby reducing overall operating expenses.
- A low EMR reflects a lower risk level, which enhances the company's reputation for safety.
- A low EMR can open up more business opportunities and help build trust with clients and partners.
What is Bad EMR?
A bad EMR rating is generally characterized by a score above 1.0, which is viewed negatively.
This high rating suggests that the company has either experienced more workplace injuries than anticipated or incurred substantial claims costs.
Two primary types of claims contribute to a bad EMR: frequent small claims and large, severe claims. Inadequate safety programs can also lead to a higher EMR.
What is The Importance of an EMR Rating?
The Experience Modification Rate (EMR) is an important factor that has a direct link to the insurance premiums that a company has to pay for its worker's compensation insurance.
Hence, a lower EMR is indicative of good safety performance, therefore lower insurance prices and better control of risks.
On the other hand, a higher EMR may lead to higher insurance costs and indicate unsound safety procedures.
In addition to cost issues, the low EMR also improves a company’s image and its competitive advantage, mainly in the sectors where safety is critical.
It is an indication of professionalism and makes the company more appealing to clients and other partners and may at times be the deal maker when it comes to awarding contracts.
In general, the EMR is a critical measure of financial and operational risk, and therefore it is crucial to have proper management in place.
Best Practices for Achieving a Good EMR Rating
Enhancing your EMR involves addressing several operational factors within the company to reduce risks and future claims.
Here are some strategies to help you improve your EMR and lower your workers' compensation premiums:
1. Hire an Expert
Errors in data reporting or non-compliance with NCCI manual rules can often lead to a higher EMR.
To reduce your current or past EMRs, consider hiring an experienced auditor who can identify issues and operational trends in your claims history that might have been overlooked.
This expert can assist with your risk and safety management considerations.
2. Focus on Safety
Implement robust safety programs in your workplace.
Provide essential protective equipment to employees, involve them in safety initiatives, and conduct regular training sessions.
In the event of an accident, promptly analyze the causes and implement corrective actions to prevent recurrence.
3. Conduct Regular Safety Inspections/Audits
Regularly assess your workplace to identify and immediately address risks or hazards.
These proactive measures can help prevent accidents or, at the very least, reduce the number of claims made.
A safety-oriented organizational culture will minimize incidents and limit the severity of losses when they do occur.
4. Analyze Claim Data
Regularly analyze your claim data to identify recurring patterns or issues.
Evaluating this data can highlight areas for improvement to reduce the number of claims.
This should also include reviewing reserves on open claims to ensure that estimates are accurate, as inaccurate reserves can negatively impact your next EMR.
5. Establish Safety Training Programs
Develop written instructions for each task that your workers execute daily as part of building safety procedures.
Implement retraining, employee safety programs, and constant reminders about the value of safety.
The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) provides information and training requirements, including safety seminars, for a variety of occupations.
Conclusion
We hope that this guide has improved your knowledge of experience modification ratings, their computation, and the reasons why contractors must monitor their rating through FCA.
Keeping your EMR rating up to date can help you maintain an excellent reputation in the market and ensure your business gets the best insurance rates available.
Clue helps organizations improve their EMR (Experience Modification Rate) by offering tools that enhance safety management through centralize inspections, maintenance, and equipment tracking.
By integrating these tasks into a single interface, Clue enables companies to consistently follow safety protocols, reducing workplace accidents and claims, and positively impacting the EMR.
The platform's ability to monitor risks and ensure compliance can help businesses minimize their insurance premiums by maintaining a low EMR rating.
Remember that preventing workplace accidents is essential, so take the required precautions right now to safeguard your staff and yourself!
FAQs
Where can I find my company's EMR or experience modification rating?
Your Workers' Compensation rating pages contain your Experience Modification Rate (EMR). You may not have an EMR if you run a small business or if you've been in operation for less than three years.
What is the NCCI?
The National Council on Compensation Insurance (NCCI) is an insurance rating and data collection body based in the United States that focuses on workers' compensation.
What is Experience Modification Rate (EMR) in construction?
The average EMR for a construction company is 1.0. A lower EMR indicates that your organization is less likely to have a compensable loss, whereas a greater EMR indicates that you are more likely to.
Transform Your Equipment Management
